Starbucks faced Struggles in Australia: A Case Study for Business Students
Challenges which led to the closure of its Global businesses and lessons to be learnt.
The market giants rapid expansion came to a foreclosure! The coffee culture underestimated, competition faced in business.
Let’s look at it more closely
The big giant Starbucks which is popular for its unique coffee flavours and much more faced massive failure in the Australian market. There are different ways to look at it.
Introduction
Entering business in an international market can open huge opportunities for growth and can strengthen the competitive market which in return can be exceptionally overwhelming for the business. But the main area of concern and also an important factor which should not be neglected and must be taken into consideration. A business which is running exceptionally well in one country does not automatically mean it would run at par in other countries. Thus proper market study, analysis of the other markets, customer feedbacks, customer’s local taste and demand must not be overlooked upon.
Starbucks, an American coffee chain learnt this lesson when it failed to make its name and position in the Australian market.
Starbucks entered a big and a mature market which was already doing too good in the café segment. It expanded way beyond the needs and failed to establish a name in Australia. The local cafes there were a hurdle in its development and expansion. The company announced in 2008, the closure of its 61 out of 84 stores in Australia.
It brings to light a very deep and important lesson for global businesses. Its experience highlights the importance and the relevance of market research for any business success.
The experience brings us to rethink why do international businesses must understand the local customers, must bring the product as per the local taste and demand before expanding to widely.
Starbucks made its way in the Australian market in 2000, with the expectations of making a huge way with its café experience.
Despite being an established coffee brand in the United States with its global presence in other countries, it struggled to make a success in the Australian market. Many factors are responsible for this.
Let’s analyse-
1. Strong Local Competition-
Starbucks had entered a market which already had a strong café industry. There were N number of coffee shops which not just provided beverages but also offered personalised
and warm relationships to its clients.
Local cafés were doing exceptionally good without depending on the international brands .
Their understanding of the local taste and preference helped them to have loyal customers which was a big hindrance for the international brand.
Starbucks had therefore faced difficulty in entering a market where branded coffee was not much familiar. Despite of being a well trusted brand internationally, it failed to convince Australian customers.
2. Entering a Market without proper market validation-
Starbucks entered the Australian market quickly. Opening stores all together in different areas does not create customer demand.
In 2008, Starbucks announced the closure of its 61 out of 84 stores in Australia.
Closing down of its stores makes it accountable with the risks of opening rapidly without making a sustainable business model.
A strong learning here is that businesses should first make a presence in a market in stages with a deep understanding of the local demand instead of validating that global recognition is the proof of local market acceptance.
3. Non Adaptation to Local Preferences
Entering a new market and a new country all together needs a lot of adaptation to the local preferences and local customers.
When a company enters a new country, it needs to understand the local customers and their preferences. Thus standardising and localising the products and services in different countries is imperative. Incase of Starbucks, it followed the old business model in Australia.
It did not pay much attention to the local market needs and requirements. The local Australian market had already developed its taste for coffee and cafes to choose from. The local crowd didn’t find anything different to choose from the Giant Café chain, Starbucks.
They did not had enough reasons to switch from their local taste and preference.
4. Price Sensitivity and customer preferences
Pricing is a very sensitive segment when it comes to customers purchasing decisions.
Price is directly related to the quality and customer choices. Good quality product is expected at a reasonable price.
Talking about Starbucks being a premium coffee and café brand, Pricing is a significant factor as customers check the quality of coffee with its price and overall experience.
In the Australian market, good coffee was available at a relatively lower price from the local cafes than Starbucks that too with a personal touch which is very much required in this arena as Customers come to Sip coffee with a mindset to relax!
When all is available under one roof that too at a low price, preference definitely changes to go with the reasonable one. Thus premium is not paid much weightage in that case.
Premium prices can be charged only when the customers have a strong feeling for the brand.
Important Lessons Learnt
Major lessons learnt from Starbucks for the business students and the senior members are very practical and eye opening.
-
Local market research: Market research is crucial. Customer preferences, buying capacity, existing and competitive brands in the area needs to be understood well before launching or entering a different market.
-
Local Demand Adaptation: Local expectations of the customers cannot be ignored.
Product need to be adjusted to suit the local demand.
-
Expand Slowly: Market testing, performance check should be done prior to making any additional investment or expanding the business.
-
Stand out from Competitors: Customers should find a reason to choose one brand over another. And this is possible when they are given value for money at a relatively lower cost.
-
Service quality: Service quality is a key in any business. It should not fall at any cost while expansion or any other new things arising in business.
Conclusion
Starbucks relied heavily on its established model, but its Australian customers already had strong preferences and access to alternatives. Its products and overall café experience did not create enough differentiation to justify customers' switching.
Successful international marketing requires more than translating advertisements or opening stores in new locations. Companies must understand what local consumers value and adjust their products, pricing and service accordingly.
This makes us to believe that companies cannot grow well in other countries by following the traditional business model by replicating the same strategies in all markets. Price changes along with the services being offered as per the market need and demand play a vital role in the growth of any business.
International businesses must understand that Standardisation and localisation needs to be addressed parallelly. Without one, the other gets a hit.
A more careful and a mature strategy would involve opening of a few stores initially. Check their performance in terms of the revenue it makes in a particular time period . Additional opening of the stores should be kept on hold till the exact model required in a particular market is developed and is working well for the business.
To make the business model a success, companies can use a few parameters to check if the business is going in the right direction. What’s the sales per store, repeat customers visit, average buying value, operating costs and customer satisfaction.
If the above parameters fall below the expectations, management must investigate the reasons that are responsible for it and make necessary corrections before further expansion.
Referenceshttps://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1016/j.ausmj.2009.10.001
Disclaimer: all content and intellectual property remain the exclusive property of Value Assignment Help.